Carta, the cap table management outfit, is accused of unethical tactics by a prominent startup
Reading Time: 3 minutesThe strategy has boosted Carta’s valuation in recent years. But a prominent customer is now accusing Carta of misusing sensitive information that startups entrust to the company in pursuit of its own goals. The claim is raising wider questions about how Carta operates, even as Carta argues the incident was isolated.
On Friday, Finnish CEO Karri Saarinen posted on LinkedIn that he had received surprising news about Linear, the project management software company he co-founded four years ago and that raised $35 million in funding this fall. Linear is a Carta customer, and according to Saarinen, earlier on Friday, without his consent or knowledge, a representative from Carta reached out to an angel investor in Linear, telling the individual that Carta had a ‘firm buy order’ from an interested party at a specific price, though this buyer might be willing to ‘flex higher,’ said the Carta employee in an email.
As it turns out, that angel investor is related to Saarinen and immediately alerted him to the email outreach. Feeling betrayed by Carta, Saarinen wrote on LinkedIn, ‘This might be the end of Carta as the trusted platform for startups. As a founder it feels kind shitty that Carta, who I trust to manage our cap table, is now doing cold outreach to our angel investors about selling Linear shares to their non disclosed buyers.’ Continued Saarinen, ‘They never contacted us (their customer) about starting an order book for Linear shares. The investor they reached out to is a family member whose investment we never published anywhere. We and they never opted in to any kind of secondary sales. Yet Carta Liquidity found their email and knew that they owned Linear shares.’
The post took on a life of its own – thousands have ‘liked’ it and it has drawn nearly 800 comments – before Ward waded into the conversation to apologize. Ward also said the email to the Linear investor is not something that Carta condones. Wrote Ward: ‘Hii Karri and everyone, I’m appalled that this happened. We are still investigating but it appears that Friday morning an employee violated our internal procedures and went out of bounds reaching out to customers they shouldn’t have. This impacted Karri’s company and two other companies. We have contacted the other two companies and are continuing to investigate. If you have any other information please reach out to me directly at henry.ward@carta.com to let me know while we continue our investigation.’
Saarinen meanwhile continued to post on LinkedIn that the incident seemed anything but isolated. ‘So far I’ve heard from 4 of our investors who were approached with the same email. All of them were the early pre-seed investors. Also heard from 2 companies who had this happen to them. One of them a prominent AI company.’
He later posted on X that, ‘I’ve learned from multiple companies that this has been going on for months or even years where investors or employees of private companies are solicited by Carta employees to put their shares on sale. These people haven’t opted in to this and companies haven’t approved these sales.’
Saarinen also posted back on LinkedIn last night that he’d finally talked directly with Ward, and that though he wasn’t sure ‘what details I can share’ as it ‘was a call I can’t quote’ per Ward’s instructions to Saarinen, ‘nothing’ that Ward told Saarinen ‘really changed’ his position, Saarinen wrote.
Companies typically have to approve transactions relating to secondary sales, noted Murphy. ‘Almost every board meeting I go to, some employee is selling stock and we have to allow, exercise our [right of first refusal] and sometimes block if we can.’
Murphy further implied that Carta’s process is both straightforward — and ethical. ‘With Carta, they have a tender product where they coordinate directly with the company to help a process they would run. Then in the case of CartaX marketplace, we verify a buyer and confirm their demand, and they we use public sources of data like Crunchbase and Pitchbook to find potential supply to match the buyer.’
Saarinen suggests on LinkedIn, however, that the mere idea that Carta — which works with many thousands of startups — would go around founders’ backs, using information it has gleaned as their service provider, is disturbing enough. ‘Companies likely won’t approve these transactions. Most have restrictions and would need board/majority approval. Carta mentions that in their pdf faq that ‘Most secondary transactions will be subject to approval by companies,” he writes. ‘But they still take buy orders and spam our investors knowing that these won’t get approved.’
For Carta, the unflattering attention is the latest in a stream of bad publicity. It has been so constant that in October, Ward even emailed customers, telling them that if they are concerned about ‘negative press’ tied to the outfit, they should read a Medium post of his. The move appeared only to call more attention to the many reported problems plaguing the company.
Ref: techcrunch
MediaDownloader.net -> Free Online Video Downloader, Download Any Video From YouTube, VK, Vimeo, Twitter, Twitch, Tumblr, Tiktok, Telegram, TED, Streamable, Soundcloud, Snapchat, Share, Rumble, Reddit, PuhuTV, Pinterest, Periscope, Ok.ru, MxTakatak, Mixcloud, Mashable, LinkedIn, Likee, Kwai, Izlesene, Instagram, Imgur, IMDB, Ifunny, Gaana, Flickr, Febspot, Facebook, ESPN, Douyin, Dailymotion, Buzzfeed, BluTV, Blogger, Bitchute, Bilibili, Bandcamp, Akıllı, 9GAG